Keep it professional and your team will tell you what you need to know

You can be kind to your team without being their friend. Be as warm, human and honest with them as you like, but everyone notices the imbalance of power: you approve the pay rises, and when something has to be decided, you’re the one who decides it. Pretending otherwise doesn’t make the imbalance go away. It just leaves you as the only person in the room still pretending. The fiction survives right up until the day you have to use that power, to give hard feedback, say no or restructure, and at that point it feels like a betrayal.

The second cost is harder to spot, and it’s about information. Looking down the organisation, everything you see has been filtered, and the more layers there are below you, the more you’re handed a tidy summary of a reality you’ve lost sight of. Coming up towards you, it gets held back, sometimes out of kindness: someone sits on bad news because they don’t want to spoil a good working relationship. They mean well, but you end up deciding on the strength of a picture you know is incomplete, and piecing the truth together through back channels.

Getting tougher won’t fix this. What will is not relying on the official line alone. Stay in direct, regular contact with a handful of people at each level below you, and with peers elsewhere in the organisation, without going over anyone’s head and openly enough that nobody mistakes it for spying. Be honest about what the relationship is, and set up your own ways of finding out what never comes through the official channel.